Out Of The Frying Pan And Into The Fire

Blair tried to spin his announcement of a reduction of British troop levels in Iraq as some kind of victory by telling us that the situation was now safe enough for a handover to Iraqi control. Obviously this is contrary to the evidence coming out of Basra where troops seem to be largely confined to base and liable to be attacked as soon as they venture out.

In a comment entitled "The British Defeat in Iraq" the pre-eminent American analyst on Iraq, Anthony Cordesman of the Centre for Strategic and International Studies, in Washington, asserts that British forces lost control of the situation in and around Basra by the second half of 2005.

Now we are hearing of another reason for the proposed troop reduction. Yep, they're going straight to Afghanistan. 1,600 soldiers leave Basra and more than 1,000 are off to Helmand for the Taliban Spring offensive. So how much of a victory does Basra look like now? Tony, of course, is still in denial about military overstretch despite what his generals tell him. Presumably it's just a coincidence that these two announcements came within 48 hours of each other.

Afghanistan is turning into a meat grinder for British troops with 48 killed since their deployment. And let's not forget that just under a year ago John Reid as Defence Secretary told us that:

"We would be perfectly happy to leave in three years and without firing one shot because our job is to protect the reconstruction."

There is an interesting video piece with Keith Olbermann talking to MSNBC Political Analyst Richard Wolffe about the British troop reductions in Basra, amusingly entitled The Blair Ditch project (via Chicken Yoghurt). The neo-cons are being characteristically ridiculous over the news of a partial pullout of Iraq by Britain. Condoleezza Rice is insisting that the coalition of the willing is still intact, stressing that some British troops will remain and neglecting to mention that Denmark is also abandoning the sinking ship and Lithuania too is looking for the life jackets. Australia is still loyal to the cause and Dick Cheney went over to remind them that:

The notion that free countries can turn our backs on what happens in places like Afghanistan, Iraq, or any other possible safe haven for terrorists is an option we simply cannot indulge...

We are determined to prevail in Iraq because we understand the consequences of failure. If our coalition withdrew before Iraqis could defend themselves, radical factions would battle for dominance over the country.

This is, of course, one day after the news broke of British troop reductions when he said:

Well, I look at it and see it is actually an affirmation that there are parts of Iraq where things are going pretty well...

In fact, I talked to a friend just the other day who had driven to Baghdad down to Basra, seven hours, found the situation dramatically improved from a year or so ago, sort of validated the British view they had made progress in southern Iraq and that they can therefore reduce their force levels.

The spin never stops.

'The spin never stops'  Yes

'The spin never stops'  Yes indeed, it's a gyroscope.  Once it stops spinning it all falls over...

Just as a quick side note

Just as a quick side note Richard Wolffe is a complete wanker. He's completely deferential to authority and in a Cheney interview virtually sucked him off.
http://tenpercent.wordpress.com/2007/02/19/richard-wolffe-is-a-very-stupid-man/

Cheers for that RickB, I

Cheers for that RickB,

I must confess I wasn't really familiar with Richard Wolffe before, but I just read your blog post on him (and a few other blogs) and I see your point. He did seem to make sense on the Keith Olbermann piece though.

Such is his ability to give

Such is his ability to give the answers that endear him to the particular audience he is with, Glenn Greenwald does a good job (with less ranting)

http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/2007/02/21/wolffe/index.html

of blowing his cover, I think Olberman is great but Wolffe is (desperately trying to avoid a sheep's clothing comment) slimy.

and my final blog pimpage re: Wolffe

http://tenpercent.wordpress.com/2007/02/23/fnt-the-day-today-youve-lost-the-news/

 A   critical analysis of

 A   critical analysis of the dreadful  problems we are leaving behind in Basra is from Juan Cole reprinted from his Salon piece here
Cheers
 t

The photo of Blair (I assume

The photo of Blair (I assume it's recent) accompanying Juan Cole's piece is of a Very Worried Man. Bambi he is not.